Mountain Pies: Discover Top-Notch Pizza and Pies in Markleysburg, PA

Unfortunately at the time they were out of some of their toppings , but the pizza was so good we ate more of it than we needed at the time .

Quaint little place. Welcoming by staff was genuine. The food was fantastic. The crust on the pizza was the best I have ever had. Cooked to perfection tender to eat. We had the BBQ Chicken pizza AMAZING enough said. Try them out, you won't be disappointed. All kinds of pies pizza, fruit and banana cream mmmmmmm

Both pizzas - a cheese and a veggie lovers - were both delicious. Fresh mushrooms, etc, on the veggie one Four berry pie was also great, but maybe a bit salty, depending on your taste.

Great pizza! Loved the option to combine two pizzas into one big one. The only critique I have is, I wished there was a little more sauce overall. We had the Supreme & Chicken Bacon Ranch combined.

One year later and still probably my favorite pizza in the area! Always so good. It is pricey but absolutely worth the splurge once in a while for dinner. First time ordering from Mountain Pies and it won’t be the last! So so good! Love the type of pizza that is New York style thin and huge slices you have to fold in half to eat! The price was great! We got the Friday night special large pizza and cheesy bread sticks for $22.99. Wasn’t expecting the pizza to be giant! Can’t wait to go there again!

Amazing pizza. My family and I are staying at Outflow campground and came across this pizza place. We already ordered from them twice. This was a great find. Delicious pizza, abundant toppings, drool-worthy crust. If you are in the area you definitely have to give them a try. Friendly staff and the pizzas are made quickly and to order. Conveniently located.

Pizza and pie. It's pretty hard to imagine a better combination of things done well. Both are exceptional at Mountain Pies. I had the stromboli actually, not a traditional pizza, but it had all the things that would have made a pizza really, really good - the best dough ever, mounds of mozzarella cheese, and a super tasty array of toppings. Also marinara dipping sauce. I was pretty hungry, but I still surprised myself by inhaling the entire thing in one sitting. So good! I also bought an entire pie, a peach blueberry cobbler pie, and I will just say it was among the best pies I've ever purchased and probably 1/5 the cost of the pies I have access to purchase in LA, which don't typically have that homemade quality. The establishment itself is exactly what you want for good pizza and pie - unassuming, comfortable, warm, inviting. There was a TV with a super Nintendo in the dining area. The service staff are down to earth people who treated me like I was a neighbor. I really, really liked this place and would recommend it to anyone remotely in the same area.

I had the pleasure of finding this place after going on a hike at Cucumber Falls. My group and I got hungry, so we decided to try out some local pizza. We called in to order for carryout, the employee who took our order was very pleasant. 20 minutes later we were in front of the building, waiting to try out the pizza after a long day of driving, going on tours, and hiking. The inside felt nice and cozy, and the employees were friendly and courteous. After driving to our Airbnb, we finally had the opportunity to dig in to the amazing looking pizza. The first bite reminded me why I enjoy trying local pizza instead of the big chain restaurants. The pepperoni is the star at play here, they're so big and tasty, I don't recall seeing anything of this caliber any where else. The next day, we were going back home after our last tour, and we decided to get another pizza because it was that good. We got there and ate inside the dining area. The pizza was just as good if not better than the day before, since it was straight out of the oven. This place deserves recognition for their excellent customer service, and delicious pizza. For our next trip, we will definitely try the baked goods. Please give this place a try.